THE COMPANY-BUILDING FIELD NOTEBOOKRESEARCH EDITION / SEPTEMBER 2026
Startup
Research.
Search
POST-MORTEM LIBRARY / Failures whose founders later succeeded

Odeo

  • Company — Odeo
  • Sector — Podcasting
  • Founded / Died — 2005 / effectively abandoned 2006; shell sold 2007
  • Lifespan — ~2 years
  • Capital raised — ~$5M (Charles River Ventures and angels)
  • Peak scale — Modest: a podcast directory and recording tools with a small user base. No meaningful revenue.
  • What it built — A podcast hosting, directory and creation platform.
  • Stated cause of death — Co-founder Evan Williams wrote publicly that Apple's addition of podcasts to iTunes in June 2005 — announced shortly after Odeo raised — made the company's position untenable, and that he personally had lost conviction in the product. He then did something almost unique: he bought the company back from its investors, returning their capital, and let them keep any upside in the side project the team had built.
  • Evidenced cause — Stated and evidenced causes agree. Apple's entry was decisive for a directory business, and Williams's public admission of lost conviction is corroborated by the team's own accounts.
  • Warning signs visible earlier — Apple announced iTunes podcast support within weeks of Odeo's funding — the platform risk arrived immediately and was not ambiguous.
  • Money outcome — Investors were returned their money. The side project was Twitter. Investors who took the option kept stakes that became extraordinarily valuable; some did not.
  • Post-mortem qualityGood and unusually gracious. Williams's writing at the time takes responsibility rather than blaming Apple.
  • Transferable lesson — Returning capital when you no longer believe is a real option and is exercised almost never.
  • SourcesTechCrunch, "Odeo Bought Back From Investors" · Wikipedia, Odeo · Forbes, "The Real Story of Twitter"

Read the wider evidence

This entry is reproduced from the supplied research, with its inline source links retained. It has not been independently re-reported for this website conversion.

Read the complete chapter, source list, and methodological notes →
← Back to post-mortems